'The Temp-Agency Shield Behind Illegal Labor' by Steve

Tommy Tuberville - Caricature by DonkeyHotey is licensed under by


For those of you just now finding out that illegal labor runs through Alabama's manufacturing floors โ€” welcome. Some of us have been sounding this alarm for years, and for years we were told we were exaggerating. The reported ICE operation at Honda's plant in Lincoln, and the north Alabama raid that netted more than 180 arrests just days later, are not surprises. They are confirmations.

Let me be clear: this is not just Honda. It is every single plant here. Honda in Lincoln. Hyundai in Montgomery. Mercedes in Vance. Toyota-Mazda in Huntsville. And the web of suppliers ringing every one of them, from Piedmont to Athens to Selma. The same pattern plays out at each: production lines staffed heavily through temporary labor agencies, Americans passed over for those slots, and payroll built on identities that don't hold up to a second look.

Here's the part nobody in the industry wants to talk about: the temp agencies are the shield. The plants don't hire these workers directly. A staffing agency signs them, runs the paperwork, and warehouses the liability. When federal agents show up, the plant points at the contractor, and the contractor points at the paperwork. Deniability by design โ€” not by accident. E-Verify, such as it is, happens somewhere down the chain, far from the logo on the building. Everybody gets clean hands and cheap labor. Everyone except the American worker and the honest employer competing against him.

The consequences are not abstract. A two-tier workforce on the same shop floor โ€” one tier with full rights and a real wage, the other with neither โ€” drags down pay for everyone and guts the leverage of the men and women who built these towns. It rewards employers who cut corners and punishes the ones who follow the law. And when an enforcement action comes, we watch grown men sprint across open fields toward a tree line rather than stand and answer a question. That tells you everything about the paperwork these agencies were vouching for.

@ICEgov โ€” if you're listening, and I believe you finally are, go where the system points you: the staffing agencies. Audit them, debar the repeat offenders, and hold the end-users accountable when their lines run on fraud. Mandatory E-Verify, applied to every tier of the supply chain, would collapse this entire arrangement overnight. The 287(g) sheriffs' offices across this state have already proven local cooperation works. What's missing is the will to stop treating plants as bystanders in their own hiring.

Alabama has the best workforce in America. We don't need a shadow labor market to keep the lights on โ€” we need employers to pay what the job is actually worth, and a federal government that enforces the law it already has on the books.

I've said it for years, and I'll keep saying it: study Alabama. What's happening here is the model โ€” and the warning โ€” for every industrial state in this country.

Editorial comments expressed in this column are the sole opinion of the writer

 
Sign Up For Our Newsletter