'A Recipe for Disaster: Texas Democrats, the Death Penalty, and the Gun-Bill Deluge' by Steve


Three stories broke in the same news cycle, and almost nobody connected them.

The first: for the first time since 2016, the Democratic National Committee's platform did not oppose the death penalty โ€” and for the first time since 2004, the word "abolish" didn't appear in it at all. The second: Texas House Democrats pre-filed a bill that would abolish capital punishment in the nation's most active executing state, replacing it with life imprisonment or life without parole. The third: days after Gina Hinojosa's stunning upset of Greg Abbott โ€” the first Democratic governor of Texas since Ann Richards left office in 1995 โ€” Democratic lawmakers pre-filed 23 separate gun-control bills on the first day of the 2027 session's pre-filing window.

Take the platform omission alone and you could tell yourself the party was moving *back* toward the center, hedging, quietly walking away from its activist wing. That reading does not survive contact with Texas. The national platform softened its language; the base sprinted. The party that just won statewide power for the first time in a generation is opening the session by attempting to eliminate the state's ultimate sanction while burying lawful gun owners in paperwork. That combination โ€” no ceiling on consequences, no enforcement teeth โ€” is not a reform agenda. It's the 2020 playbook, repackaged in a state with 31 million residents and an open border on its flank. It is a recipe for disaster.

The platform told you something, and Texas told you what it meant

Start with the platform itself. Party platforms are written by professionals, and professionals in 2024 did the math: Gallup has repeatedly found a majority of Americans โ€” including most Hispanics and roughly half of Black Americans โ€” supporting capital punishment for murder. Abolition polling tests terribly outside the coasts. So the writers dropped the plank, the first omission since 2004 and the first failure to oppose the practice nationally since 2016. It was the party establishment whispering "don't say it out loud."

Texas Democrats immediately said it out loud. The pre-filed bill would end the death penalty in the state that has carried out more executions than any other since the Supreme Court reinstated capital punishment in 1976. It is the same bill El Paso's Joe Moody has carried, unloved and unpersuasive, since 2019 โ€” except now Moody's party runs the House and the Governor's Mansion. This year the bill would have died in committee. Next year it gets a floor vote, a committee chair's gavel, and a speaker who decides which bills breathe.

Yes, the Texas Senate remains in Republican hands, and honest analysis says the abolition bill likely stalls there this session. But watch what actually happens: a Democratic House shapes the budget, chairs the committees, and now a Democratic governor holds the pen on the Board of Pardons and Paroles and on clemency recommendations. You don't need a statute to end a penalty. You need a governor who never signs a death warrant. Ask any Texas district attorney what that means for capital case prosecution.

The experiment already ran. We have the receipts.

Here is the part that should make every voter in Austin, Chicago, Seattle, Baltimore and Detroit nervous: we do not have to speculate about what happens when a jurisdiction shrinks its sanctioning system. The experiment ran from 2020 to 2022, and the morgues kept the records.

Chicago closed 2021 with 797 murders โ€” the most in a quarter century, a body count that grew by more than 60% in two years. Baltimore spent eight consecutive years above 300 homicides, a streak of carnage unmatched in the city's modern history. Detroit's homicide total in 2021 was the worst in roughly three decades. Seattle, having spent the summer of 2020 with an autonomous "protest zone" while the City Council shredded its police budget, watched roughly a quarter of its officer force walk out the door between 2020 and 2023 โ€” and shootings stayed at levels the city hadn't seen in a generation. These are the flagship cities of exactly the criminal-justice philosophy now arriving in Austin with 23 gun bills and an abolition bill.

The response from the left will be that the story since then is a *good* one, and there's truth in that. Murder fell nationally in 2023, 2024 and 2025; 2025 produced the largest one-year drop in homicides on record, and the FBI's 2025 figures show a murder rate matching the mid-1950s. Chicago's homicides fell about 30% in 2025 alone โ€” down nearly half from the 2021 peak. Every serious person should say so plainly.

But look at how the recovery happened, because the how is everything. These declines came after โ€” not instead of โ€” an enormous re-expansion of enforcement: police staffing surges, a hard national focus on repeat shooters and prolific offenders, federal-state cooperation dispatched to exactly the cities now being described as progressive success stories, and crackdowns in Washington, D.C., Memphis and Chicago that the same party's activists protested as authoritarian. Cities fell below pre-pandemic murder levels because the state reasserted itself, not because deterrence philosophy was vindicated. And roughly four in ten American cities tracked in the most recent analyses still have *not* returned to pre-2020 gun-homicide rates. The recovery is real. It is also recent, incomplete, and resting entirely on continued enforcement intensity.

Now ask what happens when the same party that spent 2020 demanding defunding โ€” a movement born in Minneapolis, championed in Seattle and Baltimore โ€” takes unified control of Texas and its first three agenda items are: fewer prosecutorial tools, a weaker ultimate sanction, and 23 bills whose only measurable effect will be on the law-abiding.

The recipe, item by item

Item one: remove the ceiling. Whatever one's view of capital punishment's deterrence value โ€” and the academic literature is genuinely contested โ€” the death penalty does real work in the machinery of a criminal justice system. Capital felony charges anchor plea negotiations. They give leverage to prosecutors trying to flip shooters into cooperating witnesses against organizations that murder witnesses routinely. They give protection-conscious witnesses a reason to believe the system will remove a killer permanently. Texas juries, mind you, already use the penalty sparingly relative to its murders. Abolishing it doesn't make Texas safer; it just removes the one sanction the cartels and gang leaders who terrorize border cities fear.

Item two: the floor crumbles with the ceiling. The death penalty bill arrives in a session alongside 23 gun bills โ€” raising purchase ages, expanding red-flag seizures, criminalizing storage, restricting semiautomatics โ€” every one of which is enforced by... the same departments, prosecutors and courts being told that meaningful consequences are passรฉ. There is no more reliable predictor of violence than a sanctioning system with a soft floor and a soft ceiling simultaneously: nothing to fear at arrest, nothing to fear at conviction. Chicago has run that configuration for decades under some of the strictest municipal gun laws in America, and for its trouble it watched more than 797 funerals in 2021. The guns did not obey the ordinance. The criminals did not read the city code.

Item three: sanctuary, formalized. All four cities held up as progressive successes โ€” Chicago, Seattle, Detroit, Baltimore โ€” are sanctuary jurisdictions that limit cooperation with federal immigration enforcement. Repeat offenders in those systems cycle through state courts and into the community while federal detainers expire on the counter. Texas Democrats are now proposing to replicate, at state-government scale, the exact policy architecture that the 2020-2022 bloodbath lived inside.

The mandate myth

Hinojosa did not win because Texans yearn for abolition. She won because the cost of living bit, because public schools became a crusade, and because a 32-year Republican lock breeds fatigue. The platform omission proves the party's own strategists know abolition is a loser nationally. The Texas bill proves the wing that writes the agenda doesn't care.

Voters handed Democrats something they haven't had in three decades. If they spend it relitigating 2020 โ€” the death penalty, the prosecutors, the gun restrictions, the soft-on-crime playbook that turned Baltimore into a cautionary tale โ€” the correction will come, as corrections do, after the numbers turn ugly first. Murder declines are a living thing; they die of policy neglect faster than they died of anything else. The 1950s-level murder rate of 2025 is not a birthright. It is a lease, and leases get cancelled.

Texas Democrats are about to learn the lesson their coastal cousins did: the voters' patience with the "smart on crime" experiment ends at the first bad summer. You do not get to conduct the experiment twice and call the first disaster a misunderstanding.

The bill is filed. The platform is printed. The clock is running.

Editorial comments expressed in this column are the sole opinion of the writer
 
Sign Up For Our Newsletter